Under Eye Concealers for Mature Skin AND Dark Circles | 14 Concealer Reviews!

Hey guys! I’m testing concealer for dark circles and mature skin to see which is the best undereye concealer for mature skin and circles. I walk you through each of them with pricing and photos of after application and at the end of the day. I was sometimes also testing out other makeup, so there may be some foundation fading or mascara flaking going on!

Being over 40 and having both dark circles under eyes and wrinkles under eyes can be a challenge. I already had several of these concealers but wanted to see how some others fared at concealing my dark circles without emphasizing the texture. Which of these is the best concealer for dark circles without fading or getting dry and crepey throughout the day? I hope you find these concealer tips for mature eyes helpful!

Be sure to subscribe for new content! I upload new videos each week! http://bit.ly/2bqn8UO

INSTAGRAM | SNAPCHAT: stephmarie.7
TWITTER | PINTEREST: stephbmarie7
VISIT MY BLOG: http://www.stephaniemarieblogs.com/

How to Use Tarte Shape Tape if You’re Not a YouTuber **METHOD USED FOR THE CONCEALERS IN THIS VIDEO** http://bit.ly/2si0s2B

Tarte Shape Tape Concealer vs Tarte Maracuja Creaseless Concealer


*EBATES: http://bit.ly/2gtzrUj
Don’t forget to check Ebates before you shop online! It’s how I’ve earned cash back for years just for shopping online. I swear by it.

My jewelry box: http://shopstyle.it/l/hVKt
My jewelry stand: http://shopstyle.it/l/hVJV
My comforter: http://shopstyle.it/l/hVKD

3:04 Maybelline Age Rewind Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/5ece/
Maybelline SuperStay Better Skin Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/4vq1/
5:25 Amazing Cosmetics Amazing Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/47sl/
It Bye Bye Under Eye http://go.magik.ly/ml/47sj/
8:15 Too Faced Born This Way Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/4tmu/
Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/46oz/
10:06 NARS Soft Matte Complete Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/5ecc/
NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/5ecd/
13:06 Milani Retouch and Erase http://go.magik.ly/ml/3l76/
Maybelline Fit Me Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/47si/
15:36 Lancome Effacernes http://go.magik.ly/ml/3v5b/
Bare Minerals Bare Skin Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/4l5z/
18:33 Tarte Maracuja Creaseless Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/3gad/
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer http://go.magik.ly/ml/4065/
22:08 Summary

Tarte Clay Stick http://go.magik.ly/ml/57g4/
Charlotte Tilbury Beauty Glow http://go.magik.ly/ml/57g5/
Charlotte Tilbury Marie Antoinette http://go.magik.ly/ml/5ecg
NARS Galapagos http://go.magik.ly/ml/2nxa/
L’Oreal Lash Paradise http://go.magik.ly/ml/5bqx/
Laura Mercier Translucent Loose http://go.magik.ly/ml/2nxj/
Lips: Revlon Balm Stain – Rendezvous http://go.magik.ly/ml/5hax/

NAILS: Essie Gel Couture – Stitch by Stitch http://go.magik.ly/ml/5dag/

Tarte Clay Stick – Med. Sand
Hourglass Vanish – Buff
Milani Conceal + Perfect 2 in 1 – 03
Neutrogena Hydro Boost – 60
It Cosmetics CC Cream – Light/Medium
Maybelline Dream Cushion – 30
Chanel Perfection Lumiere Velvet – B20 / B30
Tarte Rainforest of the Sea – Lt Sand
Shiseido Synchro Skin – Golden 3
Lancome Teint Idole Stick – 250
Too Faced Cocoa Powder Foundation – Light/Med
Estee Lauder Double Wear Light – 2.0
Hourglass Hyaluronic Illusion Skin Tint – Nude
MAC – NC25 / NC30
Urban Decay Naked Skin – 4.0
Urban Decay One and Done – Med Light
Maybelline Fit Me Matte & Poreless – 128
NARS Sheer Glow – Punjab
Too Faced Born This Way – Light Beige
Estee Lauder Double Wear – 2W1 Dawn

*SKINSTORE is offering 25% off for new customers when you spend $50. Code: STEPHANIE-RKH

*EBATES: http://bit.ly/2gtzrUj
Don’t forget to check Ebates before you shop online!

*STITCH FIX: http://bit.ly/2bQ6MGW
$20/Fashion Box = 5 personally styled clothing/accessories/shoes shipped to you to keep or send back. Amount applied to purchase. 25% off if you keep entire Fix.

*BOXYCHARM: http://bit.ly/2d8L1yJ
$21/month = 5 high end, full-sized beauty items

~FAB FIT FUN: http://bit.ly/2dqzbBw
Quarterly subscription box with the latest in beauty, fashion & wellness for each season

MUSIC: Epidemic Sound

SEND ME LETTERS! PO Box 6437 Metairie, LA 70009
BUSINESS INQUIRIES: stephbmarie@gmail.com

~A lot of work goes into hunting down products and providing the links. I do make a few cents any time you click on the shortened MagicLinks if you buy from them. Full disclosure!!•

~This video is NOT sponsored. Unless stated otherwise, I purchase all of the items shown in my videos. ALL thoughts and opinions are my own and always 100% honest. Links marked with a * indicate a referral or affiliate link. I will never recommend anything to you that I don’t believe in wholeheartedly.


M Maddox says:

You should try the new wet n wild( in the wand) cream concealer it’s awesome! Works like NARS (or better)for $4.00

Jasmine says:

What eye cream do you use?

June rodriguez says:

The crazy part is I’m have a skin care routine. For the morning and night and really good products. Maybe I should try some drugstore products 48. Just frustrated!

HerculeseFurball says:

What powder do you use to set your concealers? Did I miss that in the video?

Oh Zee says:

Thank you for this review. I find that I agree with the majority of your suggestions in your channel. I also did not like at all the NARS radiant creamy concealer. It looked awful and gave me lines I don’t even have! Currently I use the Mabelline Age Rewind and the Lancôme Effacernes. I have to try the Tarte concealers at some point but they are not readily available in Europe, though Tarte has international shipping.

anna mcguire says:

I just watched your your creasing dark circle video. I’m so excited to try it once I get home from my hospital stay.

Parisa Ayazi says:

Hi Stephanie – I usually use a full coverage foundation and never really got into the concealer game other than for brightening when i wanted to play around a little more with my makeup, but I am 35 with a toddler so i am starting to look tired. I don’t have fine lines, rather 1 or 2 deeper lines under my eyes. I have the tarte maracula but was wondering if i should get something like the becca correcting or the benefit erase paste that has more of the peachy brightening to it? I think you mentioned you color correct first before putting on concealer? Have you tried the peachy concealers? What color correct would you recommend for dullness/dark circles? Any thoughts or advice appreciated!! Awesome video by the way.

adri xo says:

I’m 29 and found myself watching videos aimed at an older crowd. I’m glad there’s women who take and energy to make videos that address these struggles.

June rodriguez says:

I have super dry skin all over and I take fish oil omgea3 can you help me.

virginie clarke says:

What! Are you kidding? You can’t be over 40! You look so much younger!,! You look Amazing I have just been watching your videos and they are pretty good!,! Love your accent:) I’m French but live in the uk

Dede Vaughn says:

I have deep tear troughs and dark undereyes. I’ve never found anything that works under my eyes without looking splotchy. nothing covers the deepest part of my trough, which is probably a shadow. everything from Maybelline to erase paste to bye bye under eye. I’m trying Bare Minerals and Shape Tape. they’re on their way here. actually, of all I’ve tried, the $4 wet and wild HD concealer works as well as any thing I’ve tried so far. I’ve lost almost 200lbs and 100 since I turned 50.

Fernanda Maita says:

Wow! I was shocked after seeing this video! You did such an amazing work Stephanie! Congratulations! And thank very much for sharing!

Dede Vaughn says:

omg, I just saw your foundation matches!!! I’m nc25/30 too and that’s a God send! I have trouble matching foundation!! thanks again!!

Nabiha Hassam says:

Hello Stephanie. You have mentioned Estee Lauder stay in place concealer in a video and mentioned it is somewhat like tape shape. What is the shade you use in Estee Lauder? Also is it semi matte? I use custard in Nars creamy radiant concealer and have no complaints about it. please recommend me a shade in NYX HD concealer too and your opinion about it.

June rodriguez says:

Thank you for your help.Iwas reading my face cream and one ingredient is alcohol!that’s it.

Summer Holt says:

I have the Amazing concealer, but when I dust it lightly with my Cover Fx setting powder, it gets splotchy. Same happens when I use KVD setting powder. I like the concealer, but any advice as to what I should try?

Belbird says:

really like this video. thanks

Brielle Harvey says:

I think the bare minerals concealer looked awesome on you ! I’ve been looking for a new concealer, I think I will try that one out 🙂 I really like your videos- no I’m not 40 but I turned 28 today and my skin is definitely changing especially my eye area so thank you for doing the research for me! =D

PaTriciaMarya says:

So glad I watched this video! Thanks for comparing such a wide variety of concealers. I, too, have similar under eye issues but only used NARS and Lancôme. I plan to purchase the Maybelline SuperStay, Milani and Tarte Shape Tape. Tfs, Bye4Now…

Dynielle Kent says:

Thank you sincerely! This is super informative!

michele michele.nunes says:

Im over 40 and im so happy to findo out this video once 90% of tutorials for mature skin on youtube here in Brazil are made for young women. So, its excelent watch a video by a 40’s lady perspective. Thank u very much.

Patsy M says:

Awesome review and comparisons! Thank you so much!

Donna Potier says:

Hi Stephanie! Don’t stress about your dark circles cause mine have yours beat! I have to set also to try and cover. What I would like to ask you is what do you use to set your under eyes? And what do you find is the fest drugstore councilor?

Carrie Webster says:

OMG I thought I was the only one who hated NARS creamy radiant. I also love BareMinerals concealer. Will try the Tarte concealers!

Hannah says:

Hi ! I have a medium skintone(brown) from thailand , I want to buy Age Rewind neutralizer , If t has a full coverage and it will be too bright on my undereye should i use a correcting cream ?Can i apply Age rewind on my lids as well? what color? what cheaper eye cream or serum can you recommend? thank you!

gghc says:

New subbie here and I just had to comment – I’m so impressed with the information you provide in your videos AND description box! A lot of thought and effort on your part, thank you. It’s so refreshing to find someone who is articulate and organized – attributes that are lacking in many of the YT’s out there! I’m definitely coming back for more! -gretchen

jane valentine says:

Great comparisons and photos! Thank you!

Elizabeth Castrejon says:

What’s a good eye cream from the drugstore for fine lines thank you

Missy Cosby says:

Thanks for this review. It’s incredibly helpful. I’ve been having the most difficult time finding a good concealer and feel as if I’m wasting so much money. I have texture, dark circles, and find lines as well as being dry under my eyes so setting with powder is difficult. What powder do you use?

Rachelle Kane says:

I would also really appreciate some much needed guidance in under eye setting powders…i have invested in many, not sure if im using them wrong/too heavily….sending out an s.o.s ♥~you stephanie

Cat Henes says:

Such a challenge once I find a concealer that does pretty well then it usually settles right in the lines that I have in the same area as the dark circles. Sometimes I wish I could just say the heck with it and go bare faced lol.

Kim Daniel says:

What a marvelous video so much time and effort w/excellent pics all appreciated greatly. Ive not bought a piece of drugstore makeup save two lip products in over 10 yrs but I will purposely make a trip to drugstore to pick up the Milani concealer asap. There are a couple others I was surprised to see how well they did such as the Bare Minerals serum concealer and the Maracuja which I will be ordering. Wonderful to find there are some choices that worked so well!

Ivanalese Sappho says:

Love your time-stamping!

Sonia Avalos says:

Eye cream review …please .

Beauti By Angela says:

Thank you for this! I am 35 with bad dark circles & bad wrinkles & dryness. What are your top 3 eye creams?

Vicky Medrano says:

Best review ever!! Thanks so much for the close up on all angles! that was really useful!! 🙂

Salomé Vaquero says:

You are sooo beautiful.

Helene Lazar says:

Your lipstick and that color shirt look beautiful on you

Ashley Joers says:

Hey Stephanie. I am also soooo dry under my eyes. I feel like I have moisturized, hydrated, moisturized again and it never fails that flakes appear immediately right when I apply my concealer. How do you moisturize your under eyes?

Glynis Maruk says:

Yes, thank you so much for breaking so many down for us.

Lisa G says:

This is such a great video! I’m so sorry that a bigger YouTuber is copying you on some of your content. I love your channel!

Alexandra Rodriguez says:

this is literally THE best concealer review I have ever seen on youtube. The fact that you show the real picture screenshots and compare one concealer on each eye and then also wear throughout the day….so above and beyond what I’ve seen any other beauty youtuber do as far as reviews. LOVE IT and thank you!

 Write a comment


Do you like our videos?
Do you want to see more like that?

Please click below to support us on Facebook!