Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil Reviews | Cruelty Free

Cruelty free Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil Reviews today! Because why buy expensive brow products when cheap ones work, too? We’re talking about Kokie, Milani, Jordana and ELF! Leave me your favorites and recommendations down in the comments! xo

Let’s be FRIENDS
Instagram: https://instagram.com/robinscup/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/robinscup
Snapchat: robinscup

Recent Videos:

Under $10 at Sephora! https://youtu.be/S0dGFOrd4ak
February Drugstore Faves: https://youtu.be/5Sv-83hMQkk
Makeup Declutters: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjv5x46pdLE2TC6shmW5UcGhCKlvJ4w5Z
Disappointing Products: https://youtu.be/S-uXyi-39T0
Makeup NOT to Buy https://youtu.be/H1elJn04SOU

Products Mentioned:

Kokie Cosmetics Precision Brow in Ash Brown http://go.magik.ly/ml/a1s6/
Milani EasyBrow in Natural Taupe http://go.magik.ly/ml/a1sc/
Jordana Quickbrow Micro Pencil in Natural Taupe
Wet n Wild Ultimatebrow Retractable Brow Pencil in Ash Brown http://go.magik.ly/ml/a1sd/
Elf Instant Lift Eyebrow Pencil in Taupe http://go.magik.ly/ml/9rg9/

*Some links are affiliates. This means I may receive a small commission if you shop through those links. None of the content is sponsored.


Angela Nader says:

Try the LA Girl Shady Slim..I’m interested in hearing your thoughts.

Merrose Abellera says:

I love the wet n wild one because it helps me fill in my brows and shape them too unlike the precise tip one’s personally hope there’s a part 3

Savannah O'Brien says:

I love the L’Oreal Brow Stylist Definer! I use blonde, dark blonde, and light brunette lol just depends on if I got my hair done that month! They’re amazing. No one really talks about them!

pauletti says:

I use the NYX Micro brow pencil – it is very close to the ABH Brow wiz

Cara Mirabella says:

When can we meet the pup?
And I use two eyebrow pencils: the Elf one plus the NYX Micro Brow pencil.

Julie Aronson says:

I prefer a triangle shape and pencils that are not super pigmented, so I definitely need to give the wet n wild a try!

Jena Froese says:

Yessss the eyebrow pencil is literally one of my most crucial products hahah. I am so NOT well versed in drugstore products so I found this very useful!! Ahhhh no spoolie is a deal breaker for me!

Video Game Angel says:

Your kitty looks a lot like mine! Is he all black? Mine is and has that little white patch on his chest. 🙂 As for eyebrow products, I’ve tried 2, the Nyx Micro Brow in Ash Brown and the Wet n Wild Color Icon Brow Pencil in Brunettes Do It Better. The issue I have is that I can’t find a cool tone brown so both make my brows look way warmer then they are naturally.

Dee Aye says:

Thank you for the price comparisons in this video ! Well done! E.L.F one and the Milani are my favorites since both taupes work for me.

Samantha Price says:

When you don’t use brow pencils but you still have to watch your favorite youtuber 🙂

Jessica Walsh says:

I love the Elf one!!! I also use the Shady Slim, LA girl I think? Depends on how dark I want depends on which one I use. Elf is more day time all day where shady is night time. I just gotta say, I love Tut!!!! I have a special place in my heart for black cats!!!!

Perfectly Broken Sami says:

I’ve heard the LA girl is a good one. I’ve bought the L’Oréal Micro Brow Stylist n I don’t know of I like it. I have the elf one n I would like it better if the tip was more precise

Shawna Yuan says:

Nicole Renee Cutler recommends the LA Girl Shady Slim brow pencil, have you tried it? I personally use the Nyx Micro Brow

EVRL says:

I tried the elf brow pencil and I did not like it because the product clings on to my eyebrow hairs because it’s dry and it makes my eyebrows look awful

Macki Pierce says:

ouch on the Tut shoulder bite!!

Christy Fielding says:

I like the L’Oréal brow stylist and maybelline brow definer I think is the name, it’s the tiny tipped one. LA Girl shady slim pencil is pretty good too. I love the elf one but it’s hard for me to use because I have to create parts of my brows that are missing from over plucking and scars.


First, Tut was very rude to bite his mama like that. That’s not how to get your way. As far as brows tho, mine are almost clear they’re so light. I currently use a Maybelline pencil or the Anastasia pomade. I’m lousy at brows tho. A new Ulta just opened up near me so I think I’m gonna go get a lesson.

Sydni Adame says:

The nyx micro.. something hahah

Eden Rivers says:

Before going cruelty free, I loved the Maybelline pencil that had a pencil on one end, a powder with a sponge tip on the other. It was one of the longest lasting brow pencils I have ever tried.

Sarah Nicholson says:

LOL…Molly was interested in Ruper’s opinion 🙂

beccaisinvisible says:

I like the NYX Microbrow as an ABH dupe!

Toni Brown says:

so I tossed all my brow products this a.m. I can’t. I just can’t. Me and my sketchy, blondy-patchy brows are just taking the helm and tallying ho, Matey. … I figured out that you remind me quite muchly of the actress Kristen Scott Thomas. you both rock, too! https://www.bing.com/images/search?view=detailV2&ccid=Nb6ZcnZL&id=8ADC57070994D2D05CA9B20786969CBC6944BCE0&thid=OIP.Nb6ZcnZLtYkCzW1Yq3i3sQHaFj&mediaurl=https%3a%2f%2fs-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com%2f736x%2f3d%2fae%2f5a%2f3dae5ac8f8a770fc984fff72eb721fb9.jpg&exph=552&expw=736&q=Kristen+Scott+Thomas&simid=608044114292509286&selectedIndex=40&ajaxhist=0

ElectricPhantom says:

I like the wet n wild one, I find it’s easier to apply right after setting spray. I use a mix of the wet n wild and the nyx, because I like the precision of a micropencil, but use the larger one to actually fill them in. Otherwise, I go through one micropencil a month

Däumelinchen says:

You should try the Maybelline Brow precise fiber volumizer! It’s essentially a brow gel that holds your brows like no other while it’s filling them in like a pomade.. And I usually don’t like pomades. It’s not the most precise but you can pick up a little of the product on the tip or a tiny brush. This thing has replaced all my brow pencils and it’s far quicker!

Kim Basciano says:

I just ordered the LA colors brow pencil from ulta & im excited to see how it works. I love the Elf one, it’s so good & the fact that it’s $2 just makes me love it even more lol. have a great day Robin!

Teresa G says:

I really like the Micro Brow Pencil from NYX. They have a soft brown shade with ashy undertones that’s perfect for me.

Elise Passiniemi says:

My favourites are Catrice Cosmetics Slim’matic Ultra Precise Brow Pencil Waterproof and Benecos Natural Eyebrow-Designer

Macki Pierce says:

Oh!! I was bored and I have some interesting info!! Physicians formula and wet n wild are BOTH owned by Markwins Beauty, Jordana and Miliani are owned by the same family … and then you have the BIGGER drugstore brands that are all owned by the same companies as the High End stuff!! Sooooo it makes alot of sense now why they don’t get mad at each other over dupes.. like ya really gonna sue your mom ?? Haha

Ann Edwards says:

There is a NYX one with a very small, precise tip

Emily Hesse says:

Studio Pro HD Brow Pencil from BH Cosmetics…..I love the ELF pencil too. When I have both pencils on hand I will use the BH to define the shape and ELF to fill in since it’s a softer pencil.

Keith Sorrels says:

Tut gnawing on your shoulder is just enough irony for going cruelty-free.

Classic Ashley says:

I love the L’Oréal Brow Stylist. It reminds me of the Brow wiz, but I like it better!

Perfectly Broken Sami says:

And you got down to the nitty gritty on those prices… I could see u in the store with a calculator n cussing the prices on each per gram..

Laurie Gold says:

Try the NYX micro pencil. Great color selection and it’s what I use after much trial and error. I needed to give up my high end products when I stopped coloring my hair and my brows started going gray. Actually, I also use, if you can believe it, a little Just for Men Beard to deal with the gray, then the NYX because it is precise, not too soft or hard, and has a good spoolie. For me, the ELF doesn’t even come close.

Alex Hampson says:

I go for the LA girl and the Colourpop ones!

earlynovemberlove says:

I don’t know if I would even bother doing my brows if it wasn’t for the fact that I can get a nice cool-toned pencil for $2 FREAKING DOLLARS.

 Write a comment


Do you like our videos?
Do you want to see more like that?

Please click below to support us on Facebook!