Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil Reviews | Part II

Drugstore eyebrow pencil reviews today, part two! What are your favorite budget brow products from the drugstore? We’re talking about Essence, Maybelline, L’Oreal, LA Girl, and CoverGirl today. Let me know what you think down in the comments! xo

Drugstore Brows Part One: https://youtu.be/gSK7ubiKrhU

Let’s be FRIENDS
Instagram: https://instagram.com/robinscup/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/robinscup
Snapchat: robinscup

Recent Videos:

June Drugstore Faves https://youtu.be/VKw-8x2OO3k
How I Survived My First Trimester https://youtu.be/GKcIeJdLTeA
Milani Gilded Desires Review and GIVEAWAY https://youtu.be/yWLaKo-RFps
Shock and Awe (disappointing products) https://youtu.be/ZZAi65x16Ac
CoverGirl TruNaked Peach Punch Palette https://youtu.be/qKihqQG00LU

Products Mentioned:

*Essence Superlast Eyebrow Pomade Pencil Waterproof in brown https://go.magik.ly/ml/dhip/
*Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil in medium brown https://go.magik.ly/ml/dhiq/
*L’Oreal Brow Stylist Definer in brunette https://go.magik.ly/ml/dhis/
*L.A. Girl Shady Slim Brow Pencil in medium brown https://go.magik.ly/ml/dhit/
*CoverGirl Easy Breezy Micro-Fine + Define Brow Pencil in soft brown https://go.magik.ly/ml/cw8u/

Also on my face:

*Revlon ColorStay Full Cover Foundation https://go.magik.ly/ml/dhiw/
*Milani Gilded Desires Palette https://go.magik.ly/ml/dhiz/
*Marc Jacobs Le Marc Lipstick in Sonic Truth https://go.magik.ly/ml/cd5h/
*Buxom Full on Lip Cream in White Russian https://go.magik.ly/ml/cd5i/
*Benefit Roller Lash https://go.magik.ly/ml/c9pt/

*These links are affiliates. If you shop through these links, I will receive a small commission at no cost to you. Thank you for supporting my channel! None of the content is sponsored.


Jennifer Mello says:

I do like the temptation

Sarah Nicholson says:

Interesting!!! I don’t fill in my brows, they’re pretty thick, like 80’s thick, even waxed…but I have been wondering about brow pencils as I do have a “scar” in my right eyebrow. I just don’t know if I will make the effort lol

Kim Basciano says:

I love drugstore eyebrow pencils!!

Anjanae Rizwan says:

Im always looking for a brow pencil cheaper than my benefits one, but I love it soooo much. If I can get a pencil similar to it…I’m sold

Crystal C says:

I like the Maybelline one I haven’t tried all of them, but two of the five

jcjccmz says:

I love your cursing lol

jcjccmz says:

I’ll have to try LA Girl next. I’ve never tried anything by LA Girl, but trying different brow pencils is an addiction. My favorite is L’Oreal, but Maybelline has a newer microbrow pencil too and I picked it up last week and I like that one too. Both are similar price per gram.

MathIsMagical says:

I love the NYX precision brow pencil. It’s much more expensive then the ones you have in your video but it last me a really long time.

KBellaBeauty says:

It’s so hard for me to find an eyebrow pencil that matches my hair color… So I usually just stick to my ABH products.

Teresa G says:

I totally agree with you about the CoverGirl pencil. My brows are also an ashy light brown and it’s the perfect shade/formula for me.

april anne says:

We have the exact same brow color, so I appreciate this :3 thank!

T Hynson says:

I never used anything besides clear eyebrow gel before a few months ago. I have crazy Brook Shields eyebrows. However, I have recently learned to appreciate an eyebrow pencil for those times when my plucking goes wacky and the shape looks crazy. I only have 2 and they’re the Maybelline brow precise and Maybelline total temptation. Of the 2 I like the brow precise better, but I do really like the spoolie on the total temptation.

Jesika N says:

I swear you look like kristen cavallari

Kelly Wolfe says:

Thanks for sharing

Lisette's wonderland says:

I love how honest you are with your reviews and very explanatory, thank you this helped alot❤❤❤

Cassie Winkler says:

Great video! I’ve tried all of them but Essence. I didn’t like the Maybelline. I think it is more waxy? LA girl was definitely my favorite too!

Karen Vix says:

this video really helped bc i need to stop buying ABH brow pencils! hopefully you could check out my channel!

Ganja Girl says:

You need more subs! Wtf. Your videos are professional and you get right to the point :p i like your personality too. You just gained a new loyal sub. Ill be here every step of the way to watch and help you grow.

jcjccmz says:

Who are we kidding? You have to do a part 3, because that NYX microbrow pencil is what everyone talks about. Btw, there is a Maybelline Tattoo brow ink thing and you can do a PSA by trying it and letting people know how terrible it is. I bought one in medium brown and the factory had broken one of the tips and the color was too warm. So I exchanged it for the dark/deep brown and it just sucks. Useless.

Christy Fielding says:

I’m not crazy about the la girl one I felt like it was a little too waxy for me I have to recreate some parts of my brows. Of these 5 the L’Oréal is my favorite although I’ve not tried the covergirl one. I also have an obsession with brow pencils. I’ve tried so many right now my faves are colourpop brow boss and BH Cosmetics idk the name but it’s the tiny tipped one lol.

Samantha Rausch says:

Great review! love drugstore ❤❤❤

Brian Pierce says:

Girl I went to Wal-Mart looking for a brown pencil and got so excited when I saw the girl stocking the loreal peach palette that I forgot about my brown stuff lol!!(this is Macki Perce I forgot.to charge my phone so I took my husband’s lol)

Julie Aronson says:

I don’t like creamy pencils but the maybelline one is really nice!

Virginia Holliday says:


Mom Life says:

Great Review…I love the e.l.f. brow pencil for $2 you can’t beat the price and it last me around 2 months with steady use.

Kaily Baute says:


Ginni Terhune says:

What is your top recommemdation?

Perfectly Broken Sami says:

I have the Colourpop eyebrow pencil n it’s pretty good… I’ve wanted to try the NYX one but haven’t found it yet. I’m all about the cool tone brows… I feel like my brows turn orange with some pencils… lol

Squirrel_Of_Mistri says:

Thanks for this video. 🙂 My brows really suck, and I need something new to make them not suck so much.

 Write a comment


Do you like our videos?
Do you want to see more like that?

Please click below to support us on Facebook!